Shutter Island- SPOILERS

[JD]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

[Slaky]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

JD and the Kapman agree on something:

[JD]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

JD and the Kapman agree on something:

I'm just providing the balance.  It doesn't "suck" really, but it's also definitely not worth the knob-blobbin' it's getting, either.

[Richard Chuggar]

Finally saw this movie.  It was really, really good.  I kept waiting for Leo to not be crazy, but sho nuff, he was crazy.  Heath Ledger's alive ex-wife was creepy as dick.

[R-V]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

[JD]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

I wish you were with me on every one.  On EVERY one.

[Kermit IV]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

I didn't read the book, but I feel like if you didn't see the TWIST coming after seeing the preview, you're dumber than a common TDubbs.  Creepy Michelle Williams or no, it was so overrated.

[Richard Chuggar]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

I didn't read the book, but I feel like if you didn't see the TWIST coming after seeing the preview, you're dumber than a common TDubbs.  Creepy Michelle Williams or no, it was so overrated.

We get it, you finally remembered your Insipio password.

[SKO]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

I didn't read the book, but I feel like if you didn't see the TWIST coming after seeing the preview, you're dumber than a common TDubbs.  Creepy Michelle Williams or no, it was so overrated.

Harumph.

[Powdered Toast Man]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

I didn't read the book, but I feel like if you didn't see the TWIST coming after seeing the preview, you're dumber than a common TDubbs.  Creepy Michelle Williams or no, it was so overrated.

Overrated or overhyped?  Or both?  Either way, I still thought it was a good movie.

[Kermit IV]

I thought it was really well made. I felt like I was going crazy toward the end and wondered if I could know if I was crazy. HOW WOULD I KNOW?!? HOW WOULD YOU KNOW?!? I'm still not convinced that those goddamned McCarthy fascists didn't set Daniels up.

Well, since Chuck D inserted the spoiler, I'll just say that the look on Michelle William's face when she said the thing about her school being in session on Saturdays after she drowned the kids MAY have caused me to piss myself in terror. May have.

I dislike her but she was excellent in this movie. Damn the more I think about it, the better it gets.

You guys are weird.  This movie was NOT that good.

I'm with JD on this one. But I think it's because I read the book first. Already knowing the TWIST going into the movie took the zazz out of it.

I didn't read the book, but I feel like if you didn't see the TWIST coming after seeing the preview, you're dumber than a common TDubbs.  Creepy Michelle Williams or no, it was so overrated.

Overrated or overhyped?  Or both?  Either way, I still thought it was a good movie.

I don't really care about hype, so overrated.